Bernie Williams - Hall of Famer?

[ironmanfan]

Re: Bernie Williams - Hall of Famer?

If there was a Hall of Good, I'd nominate Bernie

[BULBUS]

Re: Bernie Williams - Hall of Famer?

And DON MATTINGLY ! ! ! !

[GameBats]

Re: Bernie Williams - Hall of Famer?

I was a Big fan of Thurman Munson, but He couldn't hold a candle to Bernie Williams. If Munson is a consideration Williams is a lock. Just my opinion.

[stkmtimo]

Re: Bernie Williams - Hall of Famer?

Without his 4 World Series rings, I'd say "Very, very close, but no cigar". As a huge Yankees fan, I really admire Bernie and think he is one of the game's classiest and most underappreciated stars. I truly believe that the 4 World Series rings will be what propel him into the Hall of Fame. While others may argue that similar players should be in (Jim Rice for argument's sake), many lack the World Series championships that can make or break a player's Hall of Fame chances. I'll go out on a limb and say Bernie gets in one day.

Tim

[byergo]

Re: Bernie Williams - Hall of Famer?

NY Yankees: Best team money can buy. All 2nd tier Yankee stars should make the HOF. Yeah right! Get a grip guys!

[ChrisCavalier]

Re: Bernie Williams - Hall of Famer?

Without his 4 World Series rings, I'd say "Very, very close, but no cigar". As a huge Yankees fan, I really admire Bernie and think he is one of the game's classiest and most underappreciated stars. I truly believe that the 4 World Series rings will be what propel him into the Hall of Fame. While others may argue that similar players should be in (Jim Rice for argument's sake), many lack the World Series championships that can make or break a player's Hall of Fame chances. I'll go out on a limb and say Bernie gets in one day.

Tim

Rumor has it that Bernie Williams heard about this thread right before yesterday's game

http://sports.yahoo.com/mlb/recap;_ylt=AtaK3SlmDAVP_jkTWJvTLrwRvLYF?gid=260827103&prov=ap

-Chris