Results 1 to 10 of 16
Thread: Ty Cobb records from the 1920's
Hybrid View
-
09-22-2006, 02:07 PM #1
- Join Date
- Aug 2005
- Posts
- 155
Re: Ty Cobb records from the 1920's
Hey jboosted,
Thanks for your thoughts. Let me now ask a follow-up question.
Let's say I'd like to get a Ty Cobb professional model game used bat. Of course, I'd like to get a fully-documented side-written bat that has ideal player characteristics and matches exactly to know Cobb specs. But, I cannot afford the $100K+++ that it would take to add this bat to my collection - even if i could find one for sale.
From my research, I believe a more affordable purchase would be a 1921-31 pro model bat that is of proper length (34.5" plus or minus a bit) and weighing somewhere in the 35-38 ounce neighborhood. Based on recent auction prices, I figure a bat like this would sell for about $40-60K, which is still beyond my budget.
Okay, what can I afford? Let's say I'm being offered a 1921-31 pro model 33" bat with a hand turned knob, weight within an acceptable range (35-38 ounces), and decent player characteristics (excellent use, remnants of handle tape and a bunch of cleat marks, but no tobbacco juice). So, clearly this bat has good value, but not nearly as much value as the bats described above. What's a decent price? I figure somewhere between 25-35% of the 1921-31 bat described that goes for $40-60K. So, that computes to a range of $10-21K. What do ya think?
Kevin Kasper
-
09-22-2006, 03:08 PM #2
- Join Date
- Aug 2005
- Posts
- 213
Re: Ty Cobb records from the 1920's
Although no document proof, I believe within reason that Cobb might have used a 33 inch bat. the Player characteristics are key. I know that in the later part of his career, i have seen numerous photos with White tape. (21-31) personally, I would have to see the photos to make a more sound judgment. As you know, Cobb choked up and typically had his hands separated through his swing. The tape remnats might show some evidence towards this. what i mean is, that since he choked up, the tape may not have went alll the way to the knob, and the depressions (from his hands) may show separation. It depends on how much tape is left. My Cobb pro model bat 1914-15 has black tape, 10 inches long, not all the way to the knob (but close) and the remnats are stronger in the areas where he would have put his hands. (pressure from grip)
Now the above is all theory, but can be backed up from pictures.
-
09-22-2006, 07:04 PM #3
- Join Date
- Oct 2005
- Posts
- 1,349
Re: Ty Cobb records from the 1920's
Hi Kevin--
I appreciate both your comments and Justin's. As he correctly mentions, I place significant value on documented records where those records exist and are in sufficient enough number to establish an apparently reliable pattern. Is that too conservative ? Maybe some collectors think so. Regardless, for the most part, I believe that the records speak for themselves -- as collectors and potential buyers, each of us has to determine what reasonable conclusions can be drawn from a complete analytical examination of all existing facts.
Are there 'reliable records' other than documented factory records? Certainly. Photographic evidence is often compelling in determining individual use characteristics. But, again, conclusions should be reasoned. For instance, show me a photo of, say, Mickey Cochrane at bat using a Kork Grip H & B bat, and it is clear evidence that he used a Kork Grip bat (on at least one occasion) even though there is no documented notation in his factory records. That is compelling and reasonable. However, show me a photo of Cochrane standing in front of the Tiger dugout talking to a teammate, and 20 feet away lying on the ground is a Kork Grip bat ?? Don't try to convince me that it is reasonable to use this as 'evidence' that Cochrane used or even may have used a Kork Grip bat.
Relative to the Cobb bat, since the original post and responses I have seen a photo, while doing non-related research, that suggests a Cobb model (made for him), indexed and diagrammed at what appears to be 34 inches in length, I am attempting to get some clarification on the photo, but have had no response from wither the photographer or author of the book to date. For those interested, check out page 44 of Bob Hill's Crack of the Bat.
So, the question here is how, and through what reasoning, do you place a 33 inch bat into Cobb's hands? Numerous players ordered Cobb model bats during the period, including Joe Sewell, Riggs Stephenson, and Heine Manush. The stamping on those bats is unclear. How about some of Cobb's own teammates, such as Pinky Hargrove, Chick Galloway, and Jackie Tavener, all of whom were physically between 5 and 8 inches shorter than Cobb, and would possibly be comfortable with a 33 inch bat of their famous teammate. What is the answer?
That's the problem -- we just don't know. We can speculate all day and night about 'what might have been," but ultimately, the decision is how comfortable is a collector with any given conclusion based on demonstrable facts. In this case, would you be $50 confortable, $12,000 confortable, or $40,000 confortable with a 33 inch Ty Cobb professional model bat (not documented in Cobb's existing records -- either in 18 orders from 1921-1928, two diagrammed index bats, or his H & B display bat) with professional game use that is difficult to attribute to any specific player?
Again, there is no right or wrong answer, just information to help in establishing a comfort level.
Good Luck in future collecting, and thanks for the thought-provoking posts.
Mike Jackitout7@aol.com
-
09-22-2006, 07:29 PM #4
- Join Date
- Aug 2005
- Posts
- 213
Re: Ty Cobb records from the 1920's
I agree, COMFORTABILITY (is that a word??) is exactly it. Also, demand, timing, auctions play a part too, when you start talking about THOUSANDS and THOUSANDS of dollars, these items can flunctuate up and down..up and down..
When I purchase, I look for the "Good Deals"...I feel "comfortable" with.
A 34 inch Cobb bat with "Cobb" characteristics, photo, tape pattern..etc..blah blah blah at a "good deal" price... Im all over it..
A 33 inch " " " " " " " at what price?? well that depends...with my COMFORTABILITY!! (i think its a word...)
-
09-22-2006, 08:47 PM #5
- Join Date
- Aug 2005
- Posts
- 155
Re: Ty Cobb records from the 1920's
-
09-22-2006, 11:26 PM #6
- Join Date
- Oct 2005
- Posts
- 1,349
Re: Ty Cobb records from the 1920's
I certainly will Kevin...
Hopefully we will be able to get some additional information within the next week or so.
Mike Jackitout7@aol.com
-
10-10-2006, 05:28 PM #7
- Join Date
- Aug 2005
- Posts
- 155
-
10-11-2006, 05:19 PM #8
- Join Date
- Aug 2005
- Posts
- 213