I've been having an ongoing discussion with another forum member over email related to making deals with players for their game used jerseys, bats, etc.

Has anyone out there come across this situation --

You show a player his original bat, jersey, etc. (it could be for his signature, etc.) and that player realizes the significance of that particular item from his career and then offers you cash on the spot for your item? or a trade for a different game used item from his own personal collection?

If so, please post stories!!