fake Shoeless jersey in Baseball Hall of Fame

[sylbry]

Long, but good. And if you haven't already read the story on Al Stump and the so called Cobb gun owned by Halper, make sure you do so.

http://haulsofshame.com/blog/?p=798#more-798

[joelsabi]

Long, but good. And if you haven't already read the story on Al Stump and the so called Cobb gun owned by Halper, make sure you do so.

http://haulsofshame.com/blog/?p=798#more-798

its a great read. I won't give the story away but maybe can talk about after it has been out for awhile. Read the PDF file too. Real CSI stuff.

[Mark17]

Wow. That's all I can say.

The paragraph that bothered me most:

"Sotheby’s consultant and Halper associate Robert Lifson also had first-hand knowledge of issues regarding the authenticity of several Halper jerseys rejected by authenticators for the Sotheby’s sale. Yet, in his letter to the winner of the Robinson jersey he stated that he, “found nothing that would make (him) question the authenticity of the jersey.” He further stated in the letter; “I was so impressed with this jersey that I chose to put it among the opening highlights section of the catalogue.” (Years later the winner of the Halper Robinson jersey at Sotheby’s attempted to consign it to Lifson’s own auction house, REA. Lifson rejected it, stating it could not be authenticated.)"

[joelsabi]

Long, but good. And if you haven't already read the story on Al Stump and the so called Cobb gun owned by Halper, make sure you do so.

http://haulsofshame.com/blog/?p=798#more-798

I just went to the link and there a breaking new story about a Shoeless Joe Jersey that has replace the Ty Cobb story. Anyways its a great website to parooz.

[karamaxjoe]

This is an interesting read if you have the time.

http://haulsofshame.com/blog/?p=798#more-798

[platinum1]

This is an interesting read if you have the time.

http://haulsofshame.com/blog/?p=798#more-798
My eyes hurt after reading that long article but it was a great read.

[Fnazxc0114]

Wow, ive heard of the barry halper collection from this site and havent realy looked into it. Spent the time since you posted about it looking into it a little more. I wonder how much of his stuff was fake? I guess mixing in the fakes with the good stuff has been going on in the hobby for a while. Or, atleast that is what i figured after reading these articles as well as the operation bullpen book.

[joelsabi]

Wow, ive heard of the barry halper collection from this site and havent realy looked into it. Spent the time since you posted about it looking into it a little more. I wonder how much of his stuff was fake? I guess mixing in the fakes with the good stuff has been going on in the hobby for a while. Or, atleast that is what i figured after reading these articles as well as the operation bullpen book.

I never realized there was much controversy at the time Halper's collection was sold until reading this. I did not realized that some items were refused by Sotheby at that time. Makes me wonder.

I imagine the really really old stuff were the items that were questioned the most and the modern era items in the collection were found to be authentic. Halper was part owner of the Yankees and had access to these modern day players. Many players felt it was a priviledge to have an item in Halper's collection.

I can see this jersey story being picked up by the national news to correct what they reported in past that has proven now to be false.

[Fnazxc0114]

the hardest part to figure out is the conflicting story of how he obtained the items. Id imagine as much stuff as he had, it would be impossible to know for a fact that the items were actually used. I guess we will never know. Either way after seeing what he did have, you cant help but be amazed. Words realy cant describe it.

[rj_lucas]

Really interesting website, thanks for posting the link.

Rick
rickjlucas@gmail.com

[mbenga28]

This jersey was as phony as the team it represented.
A Chicago White Sox jersey displayed in the Baseball Hall of Fame as having been worn by "Shoeless"[COLOR=#0000ff] Joe Jackson (http://www.gameuseduniverse.com/t/Joe_Jackson)in 1919 -- the year he and his teammates went down in infamy for throwing the World Series (http://www.gameuseduniverse.com/t/World_Series)-- has been proven a fake, the Hall admitted to The Post.
The White Sox logo "contained acrylic that was first created in 1941," said Brad Horn, a Hall of Fame spokesman.
The jersey, which was on display for a decade, is the latest fake baseball collectible found to have once belonged to Barry Halper, a storied New Jersey memorabilia collector who died in 2005.


Read more: http://www.nypost.com/p/news/local/sox_your_knockoff_3cS7HzxnCk0tZrKbJX1dXN#ixzz11OfN ctYT

[mbrieve]

Some great info on this here:

http://www.gameuseduniverse.com/vb_forum/showthread.php?t=37603&highlight=shoeless

Interesting that we are just now seeing this in MSM.