PDA

View Full Version : A Word of Caution Re: Hinek Collection Items



EndzoneSports
02-12-2006, 08:18 AM
Dear Forum Members:

Over the past couple of weeks a situation has been brought to my attention; after several days of wresting with the issue, I have come to the conclusion that it is for the better of the hobby that the facts of this situation be known. I say "facts" specifically, as that is what I intend to post below. While these facts have led me to much additional conjecture and speculation, that is not my position to promote these, nor is this the proper venue even if it were my place.

To wit...

In early December I had done some initial pre-purchase authentication work for a customer who was looking to bid on a game-used John Elway Broncos' jersey. The jersey in question was offered by Historic Auctions’ jersey (http://www.historicauctions.com/index.cfm?&fuseaction=search.List&auctionid=31664 (http://www.historicauctions.com/index.cfm?&fuseaction=search.List&auctionid=31664)) and had been authenticated by Bernie Gernay of Pro Sports International (PSI), under contract with Global Authenticators. Contacting Bernie at PSI by phone to see what could be determined about the provenance of this particular jersey, he had indicated that this jersey was procured from the collection of 49ers equipment manager Bronco Hinek along with a number of other like-era pieces that he had consigned to the auction. Personally aware that Hinek indeed had procured a sizable collection during his tenure with the 49ers, I relayed this information to my customer who placed the high bid and purchased this jersey, but not before learning that, just hours before the auction ended that PSI had placed a nearly identical jersey for sale at eBay (item #8732166668 - http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=8732166668&rd=1&sspage name=STRK%3AMEBI%3AIT&rd=1 (http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=8732166668&rd=1&sspagename=STRK%3AMEBI%3AIT&rd=1)).

This eBay item was in fact so “nearly identical” that PSI initially chose to use the same photos from the Historic Auctions’ web site in the eBay listing, setting off a number of red flags including the initial posting to another thread on this forum (see http://www.gameuseduniverse.com/vb_forum/showthread.php?t=520 (http://www.gameuseduniverse.com/vb_forum/showthread.php?t=520)). This Historic Auctions' bidder was also none too happy to learn of this, wondering just how many of these jerseys PSI had available. After both I and the bidder had follow-up communications with Bernie at PSI, the bidder was reassured PSI had in fact “acquired two jerseys from the same collection which were in nearly identical condition”. Based upon this, the bidder hesitantly completed the transaction (something which he initially threatened to withhold doing).

Due to the "photo borrowing" flap, after ending the original eBay listing and re-listing the eBay jersey with new photos (http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&ssPageName=ADME:B:BCA:US:11&Item=8739034829 (http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&ssPageName=ADME:B:BCA:US:11&Item=8739034829)), this auction ended without having met reserve price. Following the close of this auction listing, the jersey was sold (in a transaction outside of eBay, which I believe is a violation of eBay seller rules) to Steve Silverman. In researching this jersey on his own, Steve was also told that this was the 2nd of the two Hinek jerseys. Upon receipt he requested that I examine the jersey and upon examination I gave my blessing based on both physical characteristics and on Bernie's word regarding its known provenance.

Having watched as Bernie's name had seemed to have taken an unfair beating on the GameUsedUniverse forum as of late, I was quick to jump up an post a positive note, noting the fact that I had full confidence in the above reference jersey and posted a .jpg image of my letter of opinion on the forum (See post #8 at thread http://www.gameuseduniverse.com/vb_forum/showthread.php?t=520 (http://www.gameuseduniverse.com/vb_forum/showthread.php?t=520)). Within a day of posting this, I was contacted by another forum user, who had indicated that, he had purchased a third nearly identical Elway jersey directly from PSI. As the under-bidder on the eBay auction, Bernie had contacted him and offered him what was also described as the “2nd of two Hinek jerseys”, a plausible story to this buyer as well since he was unaware of the Historic Auctions’ jersey or Bernie's interest in it. He did not become aware that his jersey was actually one of 3 until my posting of the above mentioned post re: the LOO in which I mentioned 2 others. Also, in his communications with Bernie it was revealed that the so-called "Hinek Collection" purchase was actually a bulk purchase that Bernie made in partnership with noted collector/authenticator Lou Lampson.

This above information is concerning on a few points...

Two similar jerseys coming from the same collection, while unusual, would not be unfounded, based upon Mr. Hinek’s status. Three 20-year-old, nearly identical jerseys from ANY source, would be nearly impossible to fathom without rock-solid, concrete provenance. During the 1983-'88 period, John Elway can be identified as having worn three distinct jersey styles from Russell Athletic--each style with its own uniquely identifiable collar style--the fact that all three of these have the exact same style collar date them all to within a 1-2 year period (1985-'86) within the above identified Russell Athletic run. We have compiled a fairly detailed database, having actively tracked the sales of Broncos' jerseys since 1999. During this period, I know of a total of six mid-'80s road Elway jerseys being sold publicly--of these six, four transactions have occurred in the past 3 months--the three mentioned here and a 4th which sold at Broadway Rick's Strike Zone auction on 1/26/06 (http://bid.strikezoneauctions.com/Bidding.taf?_function=detail&Auction_uid1=626820). Though identical in (collar) style, this 4th jersey--authenticated by Lou Lampson (consignor unknown)--differs in sizing and tagging (includes the "100% Nylon" tag) from the 3 mentioned above.
In and of itself, the one examined jersey stands on its own, with the only point of concern having been the absence of the "100% NYLON" flag tag which is typically found on this style/period of Russell jersey. On occasion, however, this tag is missing and such absence can be discounted as a manufacturing anomaly. When all three jerseys are presented together, however, the absence of this tagging on each is more concerning as this is no longer an anomaly, but rather a pattern that would seem to stretch the bounds of statistical probability.
To four different people--myself and, more importantly all 3 customers--Bernie clearly represented each of the three jerseys was "one of two" purchased from the Hinek collection. Such clear misrepresentation raises credibility questions and some concerns about the integrity in general of other jerseys purporting to have come from this "esteemed" collection.I offer this information as a word of caution to anyone who may have an opportunity to purchase a jersey where the provenance of said jersey traces back to this particular collection and/or purchase. This is not presented with the intention of warning off collectors from a particular dealer or authenticator, but rather so that, in performing their due diligence when considering a purchase in the future, they not take for granted the "Bronco Hinek Collection" provenance and ensure that each piece under consideration actually does stand on its own merits.

Finally, I should also point out that Bernie was contacted by me via e-mail on the morning of February 1st regarding this matter. Presented with these same facts, he was given ample opportunity to come forward to address these issues proactively on his own, prior to my making them public. While he owed no direct response to me, he has also chosen to not reply to the e-mails/phone messages of 2 of the 3 involved customers who have made attempts to follow up with him and obtain clarification on this matter.

Respectfully,

kingjammy24
02-12-2006, 05:24 PM
Patrick,

Suffice it to say, posts like the one you made to start this thread are one of the biggest justifications for the existance of this Forum. They're also among the most valuable aspects of this Forum.

That said, I have a few questions and comments.

Re: this entire PSI Elway debacle:

- The Elway auctioned off by Historic Auctions: Just to make sure I haven't misunderstood anything, are you saying that Bernie consigned a jersey to Historic Auctions and the authentication of this jersey was performed solely by the consigner (Bernie) himself?

- You said that you offered "this information as a word of caution to anyone who may have an opportunity to purchase a jersey where the provenance of said jersey traces back to this particular collection and/or purchase.. they not take for granted the "Bronco Hinek Collection" provenance". I believe I understand your point here, but I think the wording and title of this thread may be misinterpreted by some. ("Word of Caution Re: Hinek Collection"..). More specifically, it could be interpreted to mean "if you have the opportunity to purchase something from Bronco Hinek or his collection, beware". I imagine the truth of the matter is that if you come across the opportunity to genuinely purchase something from Hinek or his actual collection, you should consider yourself fortunate. It's not really Bronco Hinek (or his actual collection) that you should be exercising caution with, but rather items which purport to come from him. Did I paraphrase that correctly?
Which brings me to my next question:

"..in his communications with Bernie it was revealed that the so-called "Hinek Collection" purchase was actually a bulk purchase that Bernie made in partnership with noted collector/authenticator Lou Lampson."

I'm unclear on what's being said here. Are you intending to say that:
1) Bernie partnered with Lou and both bought these jerseys from Hinek himself (ie: the jerseys really did indeed come from Hinek) or ...
2) Bernie purchased the jerseys from Lou and said it was from Hinek or...
3) Bernie partnered with Lou and together they bought these jerseys from an unidentified source which was most likely not Hinek?

I suppose if the answer was #1, there would be no issues and this thread would not exist?

I think that all of these revelations necessitate the mentioning of a previous thread. This previous thread discusses 2 PSI "80's Montana" jerseys on Ebay:
http://www.gameuseduniverse.com/vb_forum/showthread.php?t=746

I bring up this thread because of the striking similarities with the Elway.
Specifically:
1) 2 "late 80's" Montana jerseys sold by PSI on Ebay in the same week. Both are void of the 100% Nylon tag, just like these Elway jerseys.

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=8739034776

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=8739034612

2) At the very same Historic Auctions auction that the PSI Elway was sold at, an "80's Montana" without the 100% Nylon tag was also sold and was authenticated by PSI:
http://www.historicauctions.com/index.cfmfuseaction=search.List&AuctionID=31398

Note: All 3 jerseys show the exact same font for the "#1" (the font I kept questioning). All 3 jerseys show an abundant excess of material after the final 3rd sleeve stripe. That is to say, all 3 appear identical.

It's an incredibly similar situation to these Elways; 3 80's Montana jerseys, all lacking the 100% Nylon tag, all authenticated by PSI, 2 of them sold by PSI directly on Ebay and one at the very same Historic Auctions auction as the Elway.

Additionally, I believe I was contacted by the buyer for one of these Montana jerseys and he mentioned that he was told that it came from Bronco Hinek. This buyer is a Forum member.

I'm not trying to imply anything. I'm simply bringing to light what seems to be, in my opinion, some interesting similarities between the PSI Montana jerseys and the PSI Elway jerseys.

Rudy.

Bernie J. Gernay
02-12-2006, 11:54 PM
Rudy:

To save you the time the answer is #1:


1) Bernie partnered with Lou and both bought these jerseys from Hinek himself (ie: the jerseys really did indeed come from Hinek)

so, you are correct:


I suppose if the answer was #1, there would be no issues and this thread would not exist?


Funny how there is no question of authenticity, but now a question of "how many" jerseys I owned.

First of all I have no clue what involvment Pat would have with any of this or his point of the thread because none of it involved him other than he gave a thumbs up to Steve Silverman who purchased an Elway jersey directly from me. Other than him "passing" the Elway I sold Steve, none of this is his business.

Pat is absolutely wrong on so many of his points in his thread. He should have called me instead of spending 3 hours trying to put together untrue statements on a public forum. This is how people get sued. This is why there are only about 5 of the same users who post here every day. People are tired of uninformed posts by others who are totally clueless and just start to type on a keyboard without thinking.

In a nutshell:

I personally spoke with the individuals (Tom Jacobson, David O'Brien) who purchased the 2 Elway jerseys and have exchanged phone messages with Mr. Silverman the past week.

The Elway that Historic auctioned off came from me via the Hinek collection last year and was sold to Fleer at the time to be chopped up then was eventually sold at the Fleer bankruptcy auction among thousands of other game used jerseys, etc many of which were consigned to Historic Auctions.

I have absolutley no involvement nor did I sell or previously own the John Elway in Strike Zone's auction. Don't know where you came up with that one either.

These are only a few of your inaccuracies. You better have your facts straight before you intend to boldly post them as if you solved some crime. Instead of me spending any more time on this forum explaining my business dealings to total strangers I will call you tomorrow Pat. Since you were big enough to write a thread of misinformation here you should have no problem speaking to me over the phone when I call you and hold you accountable for what you stated here.

kingjammy24
02-13-2006, 07:17 PM
After reading this about 6 times, I still can't understand how Historic acquired the jersey:

"The Elway that Historic auctioned off came from me via the Hinek collection last year and was sold to Fleer at the time to be chopped up then was eventually sold at the Fleer bankruptcy auction among thousands of other game used jerseys, etc many of which were consigned to Historic Auctions."

I'm confused about the chronological flow. Which one is correct:

A) (start) from Hinek to Fleer to PSI to Historic (end)
B) (start) from Hinek to PSI to Fleer to Historic (end)

A or B?

Rudy.

EndzoneSports
02-14-2006, 06:47 AM
Having waited patiently for Bernie’s call today which never came, and since this was a rather lengthy and complex topic, I’ll do my best to try to clarify a few points.

First to Rudy:

When I was originally enlisted by an interested bidder to do some research on the Historic Auctions’ jersey, I called them and was told that the jersey had been authenticated by Bernie for Global Authentications Inc. Calling Bernie, with the intent if determining how, during the authentication process, he had determined/verified the jersey to be a 1985 vintage, he revealed that he had purchased the jersey, along with several others that had been consigned to the auction, from the collection of Bronco Hinek, former equipment manager of the San Francisco 49ers. As to whether or not others at Global Authentications were involved with the authentication process or not, I have no knowledge.

Regarding the warning, I will leave it at that and let each individual decide how much (or how little) weight they would choose to give this information. The warning can only be that of a general nature since the whole truth of the matter is unlikely to remain unknown. While I have no doubt that there are indeed a number of high quality pieces from this collection, I would also look with great deal of skepticism on anyone’s claim to having ownership to no less than three 1985-’86 road Elway jerseys as Mr. Hinek apparently did.

As to the purchase arrangement question, I believe that Bernie has already verified that he, along with Lou Lampson, purchased these jerseys in bulk from Bronco Hinek.

And to Bernie:

“Funny how there is no question of authenticity, but now a question of "how many" jerseys I owned.” While authenticity was not the prime issue here, it most definitely does come into play. How many jerseys were owned certainly cannot be dismissed particularly when discussing a collectible that exists in a very finite number. As we’re talking about a 2-year style during an era when even top star players rarely were issued more than a few jerseys a year, having three of these pop up from the same source in a 2 month period raises considerable concern where authenticity is concerned. I’m assuming that this fact was not lost on you since if it were, there would have been no need to have misrepresented this number to four different individuals.

“First of all I have no clue what involvement Pat would have with any of this…. None of this is his business.” Briefly outlining my involvement, I became involved when (as you pointed out) 1. I had been retained to examine a jersey for a customer that you sold, only to find out that after putting my name to it that you had materially misrepresented the origin of the item; 2. I had been retained by a customer to provide pre-purchase research on a jersey which he purchased at auction, based in part on misrepresenting information which you provided; 3. I received unsolicited contact directly from another party who had purchased yet another Elway jersey from you and had concerns about it, based upon his newly found knowledge of the other two.

“Pat is absolutely wrong on so many of his points in his thread. He should have called me instead of spending 3 hours trying to put together untrue statements on a public forum.”
As a long-time critic of the careless bashings that often take place on this and other similar public forums, I was very mindful that such a posting might seem hypocritical. On numerous occasions I’ve gone out on a limb to even defend Bernie, not so much as his advocate, but because in general I was so personally opposed to the type of hit-n-run cheap shots that so often occurred. In fairness, I sent an e-mail outlining the facts of this situation to Bernie on the 1st of February asking that he take proactive measures to acknowledge and explain the situation publicly (on this forum). Having declined that opportunity, he would now lash out at me for making this information public.

“I personally spoke with the individuals (Tom Jacobson, David O'Brien) who purchased the 2 Elway jerseys and have exchanged phone messages with Mr. Silverman the past week.” If this is indeed the case, then I commend you for finally making the effort to make contact. At last contact with Tom and Steve, neither had received any word from you over a week after initially trying to reach you.

“I have absolutely no involvement nor did I sell or previously own the John Elway in Strike Zone's auction. Don't know where you came up with that one either.”If you read my original post, I made no inference regarding your having any involvement with the Strike Zone jersey, to the contrary I specifically stated that it was authenticated by Lampson and consigned by a person unknown. My point was simply to point out that we’ve tracked a total of six sales of this style jersey over a total of six years, yet four of them have occurred in the past 3 months, with 3 of them being yours.

“Since you were big enough to write a thread of misinformation here you should have no problem speaking to me over the phone when I call you and hold you accountable for what you stated here” Again, I will stand by what I’ve stated as fact until proven otherwise, and when and if proven otherwise I will be big enough to stand up and admit it. A week ago I would have been likely to welcome your private phone call, and pass the context of that call on to my concerned colleagues. At this point in time, however, I would just as soon keep things out in the open.

While Bernie has laid claims to gross inaccuracies and misinformation on my part, the one thing that his response lacks is an address to the critical issues at hand. Which remain:

As a knowledgeable authenticator, how many of the exact same style of any 20-year old jersey from the same player is reasonable to come from any single source?
As an ethical dealer, having established the answer to the first question, what rationale would there be for misrepresenting this number to your customers Regards,

EndzoneSports
02-14-2006, 10:04 AM
I personally spoke with the individuals (Tom Jacobson, David O'Brien) who purchased the 2 Elway jerseys and have exchanged phone messages with Mr. Silverman the past week.

Received this in this morning's e-mail...


----- Original Message -----
From: Jacobsen, Tom
To: Endzone Sports
Sent: Tuesday, February 14, 2006 6:53 AM
Subject: The Forum


Hi Patrick - Just reading the thread on gameuseduniverse. Just wanted you to know that Bernie still has not contacted me. The only time I have ever been able to speak to him is before I gave him any money (indirectly, of course, via the auction). After that, nothing.

I appreciate you efforts on this....my thought is drag it out into the light and see what it is. If I got duped (while I will be very upset and exhaust all options to get my money back), I would rather know that not.

Thanks again!

Tom


Regards,

Jake51
02-14-2006, 03:06 PM
Hi Everyone - Just wanted to clarify two points. (and I am the 'Tom' in the e-mail Pat posted, by the way.)

While what I stated in my e-mail was correct, Bernie and I talked about one of the Elway's in question prior to the auction and I hadn't been able to talk to him after these questions arose, I wanted to share that Bernie and I are now communicating with each other on this topic.

I also want to state for the record that I am not questioning Bernie's integrity. I am only looking for some clarification as to the history of the jersey I now own.

Thanks

Tom

Good Eye Sports
02-14-2006, 04:24 PM
As per request from many forum members who know that I attended the Fleer Auction, here are 2 links to the full catalog.

There were not 1000's of GU items, much less football equipment. Most of the GU stuff were basketball.


PDF>> http://www.auctionsaleinfo.com/auction/Files/5_12732_1-2051.pdf

Auction site> http://www.auctionsaleinfo.com/auction/12732_h1FleerTradingCardsAllcorporat.asp

Hope this helps someone.

both-teams-played-hard
02-14-2006, 04:36 PM
There seems to be a lot of questions about Bernie Gernay's business practices. I was curious. I did a search of "Bernie Gernay" on gameusedforum.com archives. Is seems there are many collectors who have had positive experiences with Bernie! For example, this post from "Sal"...

August 22 2005 at 5:54 PM Sal* (Login baltimore_colt)

Response to Interesting observation......
------------------------------------------------------------------------
I actually met Bernie Gernay from PSI at the National in Chicago at American Memorabilia's booth. A real genuine good guy who says it the way it is. Maybe that's why I liked him! I will tell you that he may be the only one out there with REAL football gamers. I put my order in already for an unwashed Curtis Martin gamer. I hope it stinks like lemon juice, skunk, and vinegar!

-Sal

kingjammy24
02-14-2006, 05:10 PM
Patrick, thanks for taking all of the time and effort to post all of this information on here. I know many, if not most, other people in your position wouldn't have bothered taking the time, effort, and hassle of posting on here solely for the benefit of others.

In a similar vein, anyone could ask me what business it is of mine to make most of the posts I make on here, given that I'm not involved the sale or purchase of the majority of jerseys I discuss. The answer, as sappy as it may sound, is I'm simply trying to do what I can to make a hobby I enjoy a better one by sharing information. Personally, I still don't think there's enough dissemination of information in this hobby. Compared to the amount of collective knowledge and experience out there, a relatively minute amount of it seems to trickle out. I don't think the Kim Stigall's, Howard Wolf's, Barry Meisel's and Rob Steinmetz's of the hobby post nearly enough to satiate me. Then there are others who have never posted on this Forum..Jim Yackel? the boys from Grey Flannel? John Taube? anyone from Steiner? (I understand the folks at MEARS are trying to get their own forum hopping and so posting here would just be counter-productive for the purposes they're trying to acheive.) Why not make the effort to share information? At any rate, before I go off on a tangent, thanks for taking the time to "share information", when many others would've chosen to do the opposite.

On a somewhat unrelated note, when should you start to question someone's integrity, as opposed to just questioning a particular jersey?
That is, how many bizarre, inexplainable acts does a person need to commit before people start to think that, even if a jersey seems ok, things might not add up?
I've always thought where there's smoke, there's fire. I've seen jerseys I thought looked good on their own but the actions of the seller seemed shady enough that I lost faith in the jersey. (I simply figured that there are issues that I'm simply not seeing because an ethical dealer selling a legit piece wouldn't be acting in such a way).

I'm sure there are fake jerseys out there good enough to fool me and many others, and in those situations the behavior of the seller may be all that's left to help us discern things.

Rudy.

kingjammy24
02-14-2006, 05:14 PM
Good-Eye: I don't get it. I searched the auction catalogue with the "PDF search" and it didn't find an Elway jersey. Maybe the search function didn't work? If it did and if that's the entire Fleer auction catalogue, shouldn't the Elway jersey(s) be in there?

Rudy.

suave1477
02-14-2006, 05:16 PM
Was there a Darryl Strawberry Jersey in the fleer auction?

Good Eye Sports
02-14-2006, 05:30 PM
Good-Eye: I don't get it. I searched the auction catalogue with the "PDF search" and it didn't find an Elway jersey. Maybe the search function didn't work? If it did and if that's the entire Fleer auction catalogue, shouldn't the Elway jersey(s) be in there?

Rudy.


Rudy,

GOOD QUESTION! ;)

EndzoneSports
02-14-2006, 06:13 PM
Again, to clarify a couple of points that have now been brought up....

It was never the intent of the original posting in this thread to discredit Bernie personally or call his business practices in general into question. What was stated were the facts of one specific incident for which I was seeking clarification. I had provided Bernie, via e-mail, ample opportunity to provide clarification in this matter in a public and proactive manner. When he chose to not respond, I posted the facts of this issue on this forum, though not to discredit, but hopefully to elicit response. Unfortunately, while Bernie did respond, he did so in a rather defensive manner, never really getting to the issues at hand, which remain still. Nonetheless, I can say that, aside from this singular incident, in my very limited communications with Bernie I have also found him to be knowledgeable and straight-forward.

I am in no way trying to (nor am I suggesting that others should) imply that this is a "where there's smoke there's fire" type of issue. I have my own underlying speculations that I've derived from this set of facts and others may very well develop their own as well. I also strongly feel, however, that any such speculation should remain tucked away in one's own imagination and not bandied in public as if it were pseudo-fact.

In closing, I also wanted to take this opportunity to publicly thank Tom Jacobsen for coming forward, after having been unceremoniously "outed" in Bernie's posting. In respect for my colleagues' privacy, I made it an intentional point in my original posting not to list the names of the other individuals involved, a courtesy that Bernie apparently did not seem to be willing to extend to his customers. As such, once the cat was out of the bag so to speak, the posting of Tom's e-mail this morning did serve two purposes in that it validated that my original posting was not the complete pack of lies that is was made out to be, but more importantly, Bernie did finally make a phone call to Tom after this was posted on the forum. To this I offer a sincere, "Thank You Bernie!" along with a challenge that if you have still not done the same with Steve and David, that you make all haste in doing so.

Regards,

Bernie J. Gernay
02-14-2006, 06:15 PM
I think this will be my last post on this forum. There are a few reasons for this decision.

Although there are many good points about this forum, there are many negatives. People are into it to bring others down. People make statements about others that are 100% false. So many people comment on things that they are 100% clueless about. I may not have knowledge in every single football style tagging worn by each team in the history of the game but I'm not going to sit here and comment on a game used Johnny Bench mitt either.

The poor guy (or maybe not so poor now) was ready to dump 30K in vintage game used football jerseys for a few hundred dollars because everyone on the forum told him they were all fake. How bizarre is that?

It is no coincidence why all the insiders, authenticators and big names in the industry don't post on this forum. And the ones that used to, are no longer here. They all say the same exact thing. It's usually the same person(s) posts who have sent this place into a downward spiral with the negativity. I know for a fact that this was not what the initial intention of this forum was for.

I have to come on a forum and explain to Pat Scoggin along with others where my Elway jerseys were sold to. Not whether they are real but how many were there. Fact is they are real and that is the ultimate fact of the matter. It is nobody business what card company we sell to or have sold to in the past. Then he's giving up to the minute posts as to who I called back, who I didn't and who I'm in contact with this week regarding the jersey. You can't make this stuff up. The sad thing is that there are only about 5 or 6 of the same people who post. That just makes it more insane if you actually think about it. For the record I called Pat 2 times yesterday and 3 times today leaving a message. However, I will somehow be accused of "never calling him" soon enough.

I refer to rule # 7 of the forum rules:

No Trolling or Baiting. You will not post any topic that disrupts the peace and harmony of this forum. Please do not create meaningless threads with the sole purpose of starting a dispute.

I will no longer have to publish my business dealing on a forum which will be nice. It will be much more peaceful in day to day business without having to deal with "bottomfeeders" along with the continual and blatant ignorance of the forums own rules.

both-teams-played-hard
02-14-2006, 07:24 PM
I find it very interesting that my response to Bernie's thread was deleted moments after it was submitted. Why? Would one of the moderators answer my question on this post. PLEASE do not send me a private e-mail!

Eric
02-14-2006, 07:31 PM
I find it very interesting that my response to Bernie's thread was deleted moments after it was submitted. Why? Would one of the moderators answer my question on this post. PLEASE do not send me a private e-mail!

I deleted it becuase it was absolutely unnecessary to take one last shot at Bernie. There was no value to that post other that to do that. The goal from each post on this site should be to help others or provide information. Your one liner did neither of those.

I'm happy to answer any other questions about this here or via email at ecky3@aol.com
Eric

both-teams-played-hard
02-14-2006, 07:46 PM
Eric
I guess these are the rules that you just made up as you went along. Why do you and Cavalier insist on protecting Sal errr... Bernie? I really enjoyed the old Gameusedforum. How many lawsuits have developed because of language on gameusedforum or gameuseduniverse. I'll take "none" and the points.

Eric
02-14-2006, 08:00 PM
Eric
I guess these are the rules that you just made up as you went along. Why do you and Cavalier insist on protecting Sal errr... Bernie? I really enjoyed the old Gameusedforum. How many lawsuits have developed because of language on gameusedforum or gameuseduniverse. I'll take "none" and the points.

Believe it or not I get threatened with more lawsuits than ever now. It was about one a week for a while. It's specially frustrating when I am being blamed for comments people are making which are in violation of the rules and have nothing to do with me. It's something that I'm really not happy about, believe it or not.

Also, why justify trying to get one more shot in? You're criticizing me for trying to keep fighting off the site?

Eric

RobSteinmetz
02-14-2006, 08:02 PM
I think the deletion of the "don't let the door..." comment to Bernie had less to do with rules and more to do with human decency and common sense. Regardless of whether Bernie is right or wrong, there's absolutely no value and no point to lowering yourself to that level. This has been an interesting thread...it's pointless to clutter it with such nonsense.

Stop....think....THEN post.

both-teams-played-hard
02-14-2006, 08:28 PM
I think the deletion of the "don't let the door..." comment to Bernie had less to do with rules and more to do with human decency and common sense.
Stop....think....THEN post.

Rob,
Now I'm officially baffled. Why are you protecting Bernie? Bernie (as Sal) made threats of physical violence against me. Yes, it is wrong to air my personal vendetta on this forum. It is immature. By the way...I have stopped...thought...and refrained from posting to SEVERAL threads about Mr. Gernay. Please don't give me your personal take on common sense and decency. It sickens me.

trsent
02-14-2006, 08:35 PM
Eric, I find it sad that you have become a babysitter for this site.

I know, I'm sure if you look up in a Thesaurus for Babysitter the word Moderator can be found, but there just sometimes is too much that you have to put up with.

Funny thing is weather Bernie is right or wrong, this thread has now lead to him leaving the forum takes away from another dealer - authenticator who could offer insight into memorabilia that may be questioned.

Good Eye Sports
02-14-2006, 08:58 PM
The Elway that Historic auctioned off came from me via the Hinek collection last year and was sold to Fleer at the time to be chopped up then was eventually sold at the Fleer bankruptcy auction among thousands of other game used jerseys, etc many of which were consigned to Historic Auctions.


http://www.auctionsaleinfo.com/auction/12732_h1FleerTradingCardsAllcorporat.asp

http://www.auctionsaleinfo.com/auction/Files/5_12732_1-2051.pdf

Where is the Elway jersey? I think the point of this thread is becoming not if the Elway jerseys are authentic or not but why Bernie feels the need to lie to cover up for himself.



It is very clear that you are a newbie collector. That is ok. I'll gladly walk you through this. Let me explain how it works when a team goes into a transition stage with the jersey manufacturer. When teams went from Puma to Reebok (good example the Rams), or Starter to Puma (good example the Vikings), Nike to Reebok (Jets, Giants, Ravens, etc) the team will sew the new jersey manufacturer logo (usually a rectangle shaped box) over the old manufacturer logo so that the teams may wear it for the following season(s). This was common for almost every team from 1999-2002. This is something known by even the common novice football collector. Hope that clears up some confusion for you.


I do agree with some that Bernie does get "picked on" and at times unfairly since its always like 3 people against 1 but Bernie does put himself out there by putting questionable items out on the market (Ebay out of all places) and then replying against those who accuse him with sarcasm and an overall condescending attitude instead of straight facts or just admitting to an oversight or mistake. Everyone makes mistakes and Bernie should be allowed to also, but Bernie should not call people ignorant or bottomfeeders just because they don't know as much as he does.

Just my 2 cents

Goh

Nathan
02-14-2006, 10:31 PM
I re-read Bernie's last post....I don't remember telling anyone what was fake and what wasn't. So I guess not "everyone" was telling anyone anything.;)

Also, posting Rule 7 as a way to attempt to stave off criticism is hardly valid. By nature, blowing the whistle on someone (Lou Lampson, for example) or a group (American Memorabilia) is going to create dispute. If we're supposed to sit around and twiddle our thumbs while playing a nice game of hearts rather than discuss issues of authenticity and related issues, then what's the point?

Oh well, I guess I'm a bottomfeeder on TWO forums now.

gujerseylover
02-14-2006, 11:47 PM
Not to knock Bernie again on his way out, but it seems like everyone is knocking him on his Elway jerseys, but no one has mentioned the Colts jerseys (i.e. the Peyton Manning and Marvin Harrison) with the discrepancy over sleeve lenghts. Once he was questioned on the long sleeve lengths, they were taken off ebay and jerseys with short sleeves magically appeared.

http://www.gameuseduniverse.com/vb_forum/showthread.php?t=891&page=3&highlight=bernie

To #1 Rudy, Nathan, Pat and Both Teams Played Hard, my hats off to you guys for sticking to your guns and not backing off when you discovered the truth about his jerseys.

I don't blame Bernie for not wanting to read this board or post anymore. Personally I wouldn't want to read about my business being exposed either. I am sure that "Sal" will make an appearence in Bernie's absence

gujerseylover
02-15-2006, 12:56 AM
This ones for you Warren:

Bernie has a Justin Mccariens game used jersey from the 2nd round Playoff game last year vs Pittsburgh.

http://cgi.ebay.com/JUSTIN-McCAREINS-GAME-USED-JETS-JERSEY-1-15-05-SI_W0QQitemZ8763957227QQcategoryZ86829QQrdZ1QQcmdZ ViewItem


I don't know if this jersey is real, fake, or whatever, to be honest I don't really care. When I saw this, I recalled a post from a big Bernie fan from a while ago. After a quickie search on the forum I found this post (6th down):


http://www.network54.com/Forum/379976/thread/1124766377/


Here is the text in case the link doesn't work.


From Jim (Gridman80)

"I have been collecting NY Jets for 15 years and have been dealing with Bernie for the last 4 years. I have acquired several great jerseys from him, including a Joe Namath, Matt Snell, Curtis Martin, Chad Pennington, Dennis Byrd, Jonathan Carter, and the jersey that Justin McCareins wore in the Steelers playoff game last year (with a letter from Justin). Bernie has developed great relationships with many players, front office personnel and equipment guys around the NFL. I'm still waiting to do a deal for the Santana Moss piece he got directly from Santana...."

What a coincidence that this guy "Jim" bought the same Mccareins jersey in August that Bernie is selling on ebay right now. This leads me to one of 3 conclusions, 1) either Bernie was able to get 2 Mccareins jerseys from that one game, 2) "Jim" Gridman 80 is actually Bernie plugging himself, or 3) He had one Mccareins jersey and duplicated a second one.

rbalm
02-15-2006, 09:21 AM
"Jim" "Gridman 80" is not Bernie. I have done business with Jim in the past.

You guys are really taking this to another level. This forum is quite helpful once you get around all the "chest beating posts". I can't believe that someone had the gall to write


Rob,
Now I'm officially baffled. Why are you protecting Bernie? Bernie (as Sal) made threats of physical violence against me. Yes, it is wrong to air my personal vendetta on this forum. It is immature. By the way...I have stopped...thought...and refrained from posting to SEVERAL threads about Mr. Gernay. Please don't give me your personal take on common sense and decency. It sickens me

All Rob was stating was lets get back to the issues of why this forum was established. If people have personal issues with a dealer, non-fraud related, lets keep it personal then.

What also gets me is that you keep blasting Bernie. I am not defending him but come on... if it walks like a duck, quack likes a duck, you know the rest....

Why keeping hashing over the obvious!!

Eric
02-15-2006, 10:13 AM
gujerseylover

I have been emailing you for some time and you do not respond. I also sent you a private message from this board and you do not respond. I had a couple of questions for you, can you please email me back at ecky3@aol.com
Thanks
Eric

gridman80
02-15-2006, 10:05 PM
note for gujerseylover...I obtained Justin's jersey from the Steelers playoff game last year, from Bernie, as I had posted. Bernie knew that I also wanted Justin's helmet. Bernie also got Justin's 2004 helmet but decided to keep it for himself, as he wanted it to go along with the jersey Justin wore when he scored his frist TD as a Jet . I also told bernie that I wanted pants to match the helmet and jersey ....Bernie told me to wait until the end of the 2005 season when he would get a full uniform. In fact Bernie had this written into his marketing contract with Justin. As a Jets season ticket holder I sat right behind the Jets bench for the last home game of the season against the Bills, checking out the unifom I was hoping to get...One week later Bernie dropped by my house with the entire uniform Justin wore that game, right down to the gloves and armbands...I told Bernie that the only way I could swing his price on the full uniform was to trade back the white playoff jersey. Bernie agreed, and gave me full credit against the complete uniform. In the bygone days of this hobby this kind of cash and trade deal, or even full trades were commonplace. Nowadays it seems that nearly everything runs their stuff thru rapacious auction houses....... and people seem to make judgements in these posts without complete knowledge of the facts.

EndzoneSports
02-17-2006, 03:49 PM
And the hits just keep on coming...

http://www.americanmemorabilia.com/Auction_Item.asp?Auction_ID=26441

I'm guessing that with the annotated "Pro Sports Investments hologram" this would now be four (and counting) ?!?

Regards,

Bernie J. Gernay
02-17-2006, 11:37 PM
Pat, please take the advice of Jim (gridman80).....



people seem to make judgements in these posts without complete knowledge of the facts.


That Elway in AMI is the same one that we sold to Dave O'Brien who purchased it for the sole reason of consigning it to them. You are clueless to your posts once again.

EndzoneSports
02-18-2006, 04:10 AM
And the hits just keep on coming...

http://www.americanmemorabilia.com/Auction_Item.asp?Auction_ID=26441

I'm guessing that with the annotated "Pro Sports Investments hologram" this would now be four (and counting) ?!?

In all sense of fairness, it was brought to my attention that this may very well indeed be a re-listing of one of the same that we've already discussed and not an additional jersey. It has been reported to me, though unconfirmable, that this is the jersey that was purchased by the eBay underbidder (Dave O'Brien). which has been hastily consigned for AMIs auction. Though I got no sense that an immediate resale was pending when I last spoke with Dave, it is possible since, he:

Bought this illicitly (in violation of eBay rules which prohibit offers to buy or sell listed items outside of the eBay Web site) at a price well below the going market rate for a legitimate Elway game-used jersey and wants to make a tidy profit, AND/OR
Considering the issues raised in this thread, he just wants to get out from underneath a jersey that he no longer feels comfortable with as quickly as possible.If this is his indeed his jersey (and I have no confirmation that it is indeed the case), then I can only surmise what his motives might be. I am aware that Dave at least follows this forum, if not actively participates, as it was his reading of one of my posts that generated this whole topic to begin with. It is possible that he might be then willing/able to confirm that this is indeed his consignment.

Best regards,

EndzoneSports
02-18-2006, 05:42 AM
Pat, please take the advice of Jim (gridman80).....

That Elway in AMI is the same one that we sold to Dave O'Brien who purchased it for the sole reason of consigning it to them. You are clueless to your posts once again.

Bernie:

... and here I thought you'd given up on this forum. :rolleyes:

Since you prefer to deal in facts, let me address a couple in response to your posting:

My post stated "I'm "guessing" that... this would now be four." There was no statement of fact nor presumption of knowledge in this statement. I stated that I was guessing.
The point of this posting was to factually point out to others that there was a fourth listing (attributed to PSI), not necessarily a fourth jersey.
Of the three jerseys in question, two were sold to clients of mine--Steve and Tom--for whom I have contact information (and valid reasons to protect their interest, as I value those with whom I do business). The 3rd jersey, belonging to Dave may very well be the one at AMI, however, as I do not have a relationship with Dave and AMI us under no obligation to divulge the identity of it's consignors, I guess I have just reason to be "clueless" in this area.Short of that, as I have stated in the past, if and when I am found to be wrong/misstated/misunderstood I will be the first to stand up (as I did in my previous post) and admit my mistakes or explain my position more clearly, etc. I will not, however, cower just because someone defensively and condescendingly dismisses anything I post as a collection of untruths.

To clear one final topic, I did receive your phone message last week. Just so that you are aware, sense I don't keep the same hours as the rest of the world, my voice mail picks up all incoming calls and without caller ID, if all you do is hang up, I really have no idea how many times you may or may not be trying to call. While I can appreciate what appeared to be an "olive branch", I still don't feel comfortable that while getting mired down in whose facts were straight and whose facts were skewed, what seemed to get lost in the shuffle is that this whole flap arose over simply trying to elicit public answers to two simple questions related to authenticity and ethics. To date, those questions have still gone publicly unanswered (though privately, I believe that both Tom and Steve are as "at peace" with their respective situations as they can be under the circumstances, which was my ultimate goal). I had honestly not intended to pick up a phone and return a call until this matter had been addressed. I now may have reason to do otherwise...

In recently investigating/addressing a completely unrelated matter for forum moderator Eric, I stumbled upon something that may or may not be related and/or of interest. While I am assuming that you have likely now divested your inventory of all Elway jerseys from this Hinek collection purchase, if my theory holds water, it could very well apply to others that you and Lou may have purchased/be holding. If interested in discussing, LMK...

Regards,

EndzoneSports
04-03-2007, 06:20 PM
As a follow-up to this thread, on March 27th, I received an unsolicited e-mail from the Hinek's (who happened upon this thread via a Google search). In part, the e-mail stated the following:
"I read about [the] "Hinek collection"... We have never sold any memorabilia to anyone. I would be interested in talking to you about this Elway jersey situation. Please email me your number"In a follow-up phone conversation with the Hineks on 4/2, it was clarified that Bronco does indeed have memorabilia in his possession that was acquired during his tenure as the 49ers equipment manager (1984-'97) as well as older items that were acquired by Broncos' father, Frank, who was the Raiders' equip. mngr. (1960-'62).

It was stated that none of these personal items are available for sale and none ever have been made available for sale to the collecting public--to Bernie Gernay, Lou Lampson, or anyone else--specifically any quantity of John Elway jerseys.

It was also clarified that Broncos' name will indeed appear on any number of legitimate 49ers' LOAs, but only in his official capacity for items that originated from the team.

Whether or not this information is of value must be assessed individually. As with any assertion on the part of one party that is denied by another, one must weigh the credibility of each claim. In this case, is more credence likely to be give to the statements of Bernie Gernay/Lou Lampson or those of Bronco Hinek?

Additionally, as a follow-up to our phone conversation w/ Hinek, a quick search seemed to indicate that such claims are not only related to the Elway jerseys previously noted... See http://www.americanmemorabilia.com/Auction_Item.asp?Auction_ID=27123


Regards,

Eric
04-03-2007, 08:13 PM
Wow

This is certainly interesting.

Can we make a little cheat sheet for this thread.
Is there a master list of the items attributed ot the Bronco Hinek collection that we can look at right here?

Perhaps we can run the list by Mr. Hinek to see what he has to say about it.

Eric

EndzoneSports
04-04-2007, 01:41 AM
Eric:

Unless others with knowledge of specific instances will come forward with this information, the "master list" appears to be limited to those items covered in this thread. They are as follows:

Elway #1 - Sold via Historic Auctions to a Denver-area collector
Elway #2 - Listed on eBay. Auction ended w/ jersey having not met reserve. Subsequently sold to eBay high bidder, another Denver-area collector
Elway #3 - Sold to an underbidder of the afore mentioned eBay auction. This jersey was "flipped", being listed in AMIs 3/16/06 auction; purchased by AMI bidder #2304 (http://www.americanmemorabilia.com/Auction_Item.asp?Auction_ID=26441)
Marino - Listed in AMIs 4/7/06 auction; purchased by AMI bidder #5312 (http://www.americanmemorabilia.com/Auction_Item.asp?Auction_ID=27123). It should also be noted (again), that this is not to be construed as a question of the legitimacy of these items. Each item must be assesed on its own merits and should stand on its own, regardless of claims of provenance. This is an issue primarily of provenance. What level of importance the collector places in this provenance is really up to each individual.

Regards,

Eric
04-04-2007, 06:53 AM
Shouldn't we add to the list these Montana and rice jerseys from the below post in the thread I have linked here
Eric

http://www.gameuseduniverse.com/vb_forum/showthread.php?t=520&page=2&highlight=hinek

posted by silverschmidts

Re: Elway jersey on eBay look familiar?!?
I am the buyer of the Elway jersey from PSI. I've also recently purchased some other items from PSI, including a Rice 49ers gamer from an Ebay auction that closed a couple of days ago and a Montana gamer that PSI sold to me as an underbidder in a similar Ebay auction that ended last month. I submitted the Elway jersey to EndZoneSports because nobody knows Broncos jerseys better than Patrick Scoggins. Patrick thought the jersey looked OK and wrote a letter of opinion for me. However, now it has come to my attention that PSI has recently put at least two other nearly identical Elway road mid 1980s jerseys into the market, including the one that was sold in the Historic Auctions sale last fall. My question to everyone is: do any of you have experience in dealing with PSI (Bernie Gurnay) and can he be trusted with all of these Montana, Rice, and Elway jerseys he's been putting in the market? He claims he got them from Bronco Hinek, the former 49ers equipment manager. However, the sheer volume of product raises major suspicions in my view. For example, could he possibly have 3 genuine Elway 1985-86 road jerseys? (A 4th one was recently sold in the Broadway Rick's auction; I have no idea where that one came from). I tried to contact Bernie today with these concerns and haven't heard back from him yet. -If anyone has any thoughts on this, I'd be grateful. -Steve Silverman

Eric
04-04-2007, 10:22 AM
I went back and re-read this thread and thought something Rudy had posted last year might help identify problematic pieces.

I don't know the answer to this- How rare is it for an elway to be missing the nylon tag? What about Montana jerseys? Would Mr. Hinek be able to answer that?

Now that Mr. Hinek has said that he did not sell these items, do the facts below become more relevant?
Eric




I think that all of these revelations necessitate the mentioning of a previous thread. This previous thread discusses 2 PSI "80's Montana" jerseys on Ebay:
http://www.gameuseduniverse.com/vb_forum/showthread.php?t=746

I bring up this thread because of the striking similarities with the Elway.
Specifically:
1) 2 "late 80's" Montana jerseys sold by PSI on Ebay in the same week. Both are void of the 100% Nylon tag, just like these Elway jerseys.

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=8739034776

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=8739034612

2) At the very same Historic Auctions auction that the PSI Elway was sold at, an "80's Montana" without the 100% Nylon tag was also sold and was authenticated by PSI:
http://www.historicauctions.com/index.cfmfuseaction=search.List&AuctionID=31398

Note: All 3 jerseys show the exact same font for the "#1" (the font I kept questioning). All 3 jerseys show an abundant excess of material after the final 3rd sleeve stripe. That is to say, all 3 appear identical.

It's an incredibly similar situation to these Elways; 3 80's Montana jerseys, all lacking the 100% Nylon tag, all authenticated by PSI, 2 of them sold by PSI directly on Ebay and one at the very same Historic Auctions auction as the Elway.

Additionally, I believe I was contacted by the buyer for one of these Montana jerseys and he mentioned that he was told that it came from Bronco Hinek. This buyer is a Forum member.

I'm not trying to imply anything. I'm simply bringing to light what seems to be, in my opinion, some interesting similarities between the PSI Montana jerseys and the PSI Elway jerseys.

Rudy.

silverschmidts
04-04-2007, 05:07 PM
Having just now seen all of these posts on this important topic (the topic is important to me because I am the owner of one of the Elway jerseys in question), let me at least offer one piece of data to the discussion. I have not received any contact from Bernie in many months regarding this matter. IN other words, his claim that he and I exchanged messages about this recently is inaccurate. I do intend to talk to Bernie about the matter, however, because it does trouble me greatly that Bronco Hinek denies being the source of the jersey I purchased. I agree with the oft-stated adage that a jersey must speak for itself, but I also believe that every piece of information is potentially important when trying to assess authenticity. In this case, there was a very specific form of provenance attributed to the jersey and I relied on that attribution in part (though not solely) in making my buying decision. So, what I really want to know now is whether the jersey I bought came originally from Bronco Hinek or not. Bernie claims Bronco sold him the jersey (along with others); Bronco claims he didn't sell any jerseys to Bernie, Lou Lampson, or anyone else. If Bernie was untruthful to me about this transaction, it angers me greatly and obviously undermines my faith in the legitmacy of the jersey. On the other hand, maybe Mr. Hinek is not being truthful. Maybe he feels embarrassed to be the source of these jerseys (after all, he may have acquired them from players with the understanding that they were meant to be mementos and not mere commodities for resale). I don't know what the "truth" is in this instance, but I do know that Bernie has not contacted me as he stated in one of his posts early on in this thread. --Steve

Eric
04-04-2007, 05:10 PM
Bernie's post mentioning he spoke to you is from Feb 2006...

silverschmidts
04-04-2007, 05:15 PM
Oops. You're right. I didn't realize until now that the first 35 or so posts from this threat date back to last year. Nevermind what I said about not being contacted by Bernie. However, everything I said about being very concerned about Mr. Hinek's testimonial still remains valid and true. This whole thing has become truly bizarre. --Steve

Eric
04-04-2007, 05:19 PM
Steve-

Do you plan on contacting Mr. Gernay to find out what he has to say about all of this?

Eric
04-04-2007, 06:39 PM
Where is a nylon tag supposed to appear?

Jake51
04-04-2007, 10:30 PM
Hello -

I am the Denver area collector that purchased the jersey from Historic. Just a point of clarification, the Elway I purchased does indeed have the small '100% Nylon' tag.

Thanks,

Tom

Jake51
04-04-2007, 10:37 PM
Eric -

To your question, here is a picture of the tagging on my Elway. The 100% nylon tag is by my thumb.

Thanks,

Tom

Jake51
04-04-2007, 10:38 PM
Ok..not exactly by my thumb but you get the 'picture' :rolleyes:

Tom

Eric
04-04-2007, 10:41 PM
Tom-

Thanks. So then this link to grey flannel shows an Elway without a nylon tag?

http://www.greyflannel.com/main.php?item=2549

3802

Jake51
04-05-2007, 08:11 AM
Yep, that is correct. The nylon tag on my Elway is centered under (and looks to be attatched to) the Russell tag and the GF jersey doesn't show this same tagging.

Thanks,

Tom

CollectGU
04-05-2007, 08:22 AM
Tom,

Can you post pictures of the nameplate on your jersey?

Thanks,
Dave

Jake51
04-05-2007, 08:42 PM
Hi Dave,

Here you go. [I threw in a picture of my new addition for fun..BRONCS! helmet from 1962/1963 - the orange one with the bucking logo]

Thanks,

Tom

EndzoneSports
04-06-2007, 08:11 AM
Tom-

Thanks. So then this link to grey flannel shows an Elway without a nylon tag?

http://www.greyflannel.com/main.php?item=2549

4606

Eric:

Would you (or any other Forum members) happen to know when this Grey Flannel jersey sold? I would like to add info to the sales data spreadsheet that we provide at our web site (see http://endzone.pscoggin.com/UniPrice.xls), but originally missed this one when offered.

Thanks in advance for any assistance.

Regards,

EndzoneSports
04-17-2007, 04:35 PM
Eric:

Unless others with knowledge of specific instances will come forward with this information, the "master list" appears to be limited to those items covered in this thread. They are as follows:

Elway #1 - Sold via Historic Auctions to a Denver-area collector
Elway #2 - Listed on eBay. Auction ended w/ jersey having not met reserve. Subsequently sold to eBay high bidder, another Denver-area collector
Elway #3 - Sold to an underbidder of the afore mentioned eBay auction. This jersey was "flipped", being listed in AMIs 3/16/06 auction; purchased by AMI bidder #2304 (http://www.americanmemorabilia.com/Auction_Item.asp?Auction_ID=26441)
Marino - Listed in AMIs 4/7/06 auction; purchased by AMI bidder #5312 (http://www.americanmemorabilia.com/Auction_Item.asp?Auction_ID=27123). It should also be noted (again), that this is not to be construed as a question of the legitimacy of these items. Each item must be assesed on its own merits and should stand on its own, regardless of claims of provenance. This is an issue primarily of provenance. What level of importance the collector places in this provenance is really up to each individual.

Regards,

As a follow-up on this topic, yesterday I received another e-mail from Hinek stating, "Thanks also for that link on the Marino jersey [http://www.americanmemorabilia.com/Auction_Item.asp?Auction_ID=27123]. That was completely not from (us). I'm not sure how these people do that. It's good that you look a little deeper for your clients."

I have followed up with an e-mail to the fine folks at American Memorabilia inquiring as to how or if claims of provenance are verified. If/when I receive a response, I will post that information here as well.

Best regards,

CollectGU
04-17-2007, 04:45 PM
Is Mr. Hinek stating that he never traded jerseys with any other equipment managers as stated?

Thanks,
Dave

EndzoneSports
04-18-2007, 03:47 AM
Is Mr. Hinek stating that he never traded jerseys with any other equipment managers as stated?

Thanks,
Dave

Dave:

The question regarding trades amongst contemporaries never came up. Hinek's assertion is that any owned items were not ever and are not now available for sale. As such, claims that the Elway/Marino jerseys in question "came directly from the former San Francisco 49ers equipment manager Bronco Hinek" (as stated in the Marino auction listing) have been denied as being false.

Regards,

commando
12-14-2007, 03:54 AM
Any updates on this?

toddhead
01-03-2008, 02:21 PM
Mr. Scoggin,

Can you please shoot me an e-mail at headingtontd.ctr@mcnosc.usmc.mil I tried to go through your site, but it doesn't seem work through my work internet.